Previous Issue Article Abstracts

 

Volume 14, Number 3, Winter 2019

Special Volume on Narrating Witchcraft: Agency, Discourse, and Power 
3. Early Modern to Present Day

ARTICLES

• • • • • • • •

Introduction to This Issue: Early Modern to Present Day
Esther Eidinow, Richard Gordon

The third and final issue of this special volume of the journal takes us to the early modern and modern worlds, continuing to underscore the centrality of narrativity to the ontology of sorcery and witchcraft with articles on Early Modern England and Germany by Marion Gibson and Alison Rowlands, and contemporary Cameroon and Israel by Peter Geschiere and Yuval Harari. An Afterword by Ronald Hutton reflects on varied issues raised by contributors.

Becoming-Witch: Narrating Witchcraft in Early Modern English News Pamphlets
Marion Gibson

This article focuses on news pamphlets about witchcraft from Elizabethan and Jacobean London. In these pamphlets, witchcraft is treated differently from other crimes in that it seems to have been thought appropriate to provide verbatim evidence of this crime to its readership outside the courtroom. In this construction of the crime, the words of the accusers and accused matter in a particular, exciting way that is emphasized as a marketing strategy. This paper, however, argue that this claim to verbatim status and documentary reliability is in essence illusory; it creates an impression of an overly neat and definitive version of witchcraft events, one that can be an impediment to understanding their complexity.

Identity, Memory, Self-fashioning: Narratives of Non-confession in the Witch Trial of Margaretha Horn, 1652
Alison Rowlands

This article focuses on the trial of Margaretha Horn, a sixty-two year old peasant woman arrested for witchcraft in 1652 in the German region of Franconia. At the heart of the trial lay two competing narratives about Margaretha's identity: one begun by her neightbor, Leonhard Gackstatt about Margaretha being a harming witch; the other, maintained by Margaretha, that she was not. I show how Margaretha used a range of cultural resources and narrative strategies to define herself as not a witch. I also argue that we can interpret her testimony as doing memory work relating to her experience of the Thirty Years War, and as an example of early modern self-fashioning.

The Historicity of Witchcraft Narratives: Examples from the Forest Region of South Cameroon
Peter Geschiere

This article compares two narratives about djambe (witchcraft, sorcellerie) current among the Maka in the forest area of Cameroon. One is an older story-a kind of foundational myth-of how djambe came to live among the people. The second is a more recent story about a form of witchcraft monopolized by the new rich who turn their victims into zombies to make them work on "invisible plantations." Both stories seem to highlight an ahistorical reality, but on closer inspection both express a reflection on changes. Through these stories it becomes clear that djambe is not a timeless tradition but a flexible and often internally inconsistent set of elements. This flexibility helps explain the ease with which local ideas about occult aggression can graft themselves onto historical changes.

"Rabbi" Nissim "the Sorcerer" and the Magic Plate of Yeruḥam: A Political-Folkloristic Rashomon
Yuval Harari

The article examines the narratives surrounding a magic plate that was found in the new cemetery of Yeruḥam, a small town in the northern Negev. I trace the rashomon surrounding the plate and its context in the web of Yeruḥam's rumors and political activity. My main aim is to bring out the complexity of such a "sorcery event," the roles of rumor, inference, speculation, rivalries, and enmities in the various constructions of what took place, and above all, the role of narrative in stabilizing and legitimizing the different points of view.

An Afterword
Ronald Hutton

FORUM

Thresholds of Saliency: Reactions to Jon Bialecki, A Diagram for Fire: Miracle and Variations in a Charismatic Movement. Berkeley and Los Angeles: University of California Press, 2017
Claire Fanger

Surprises and Possibilities in A Diagram for Fire
Joseph Williams

Narrative Strategies in the Vineyard and La Viña: A Response to Jon Bialecki's Diagram for Fire
Arlene M. Sánchez-Walsh

Theoretical Rubber, Empirical Pavement
Graham M. Jones

Miracles, Temporality, and Unfulfillment in A Diagram for Fire
Bruno Reinhardt

Conditions and Possibilities
Jon Bialecki

 

REVIEWS

Arts of Being Yorùbá: Divination, Allegory, Tragedy, Proverb, Panegyric by Adélékè Adéèkó (review)
Nessette Falu

The Winnowing of White Witchcraft by Edward Poeton (review)
Julian Goodare

Magic's Reason: An Anthropology of Analogy by Graham M. Jones (review)
Annie Lowe

Holy Monsters, Sacred Grotesques: Monstrosity and Religion in Europe and the United States by Michael E. Heyes (review)
Justin Mullis

Sources of Evil: Studies in Mesopotamian Exorcistic Lore ed. by Greta van Buylaere et al. (review)
Madadh Richey

Legible Religion: Books, Gods, and Rituals in Roman Culture by Duncan macrae (review)
Anthony Smart

The Power of Godliness: Mormon Liturgy and Cosmology by Jonathan A. Stapley (review)
Christopher Carroll Smith

 

____________________________________________

Volume 14, Number 1, Spring 2019

Articles

• • • • • • • •

Introduction to the Special Volume

Narrating Witchcraft: Agency, Discourse, and Power
Esther Eidinow, Richard Gordon

This collection of thirteen essays—three issues of a special volume of this journal—explores "witchcraft narratives" over time, place, and culture. Most of the contributions are based on papers delivered at a conference entitled "Narrating Witchcraft: Agency, Discourse and Power," held at the University of Erfurt at the end of June 2016, which took up the theoretical challenge of the Lived Ancient Religion project (LAR). This five-year research project, which ran from 2012–17 and which provided funding for the conference, was directed by Professor Jörg Rüpke of the Max Weber Center for Advanced Cultural and Social Studies at the University of Erfurt, Germany, and focused on the individual, situational, and larger global trajectories of the pluralistic religions of antiquity. This special volume, Narrating Witchcraft, takes a similarly multi-dimensional approach: scholars of different disciplines, including ancient, early modern and modern history, anthropology, and gender studies, introduced a broad variety of case studies. In acknowledgement of the theme of lived ancient religion, most of the contributions to this special volume—specifically, the articles that appear in the first two issues and that set up the thematic content—focus on malign magic as perceived and practiced in the "Ancient Mediterranean," which includes the Ancient Near East and connected areas over a time span of some thirty-five hundred years. 

 

Introduction to this Issue
Ancient Cultures
Esther Eidinow, Richard Gordon

Our first issue explores primary materials from some of the earliest cultures to produce narrative evidence for notions of witchcraft. Svenja Nagel explores ancient Egyptian texts that date from c. 2700 BCE until c. 500 CE (Old Kingdom up to Late Antiquity), including narrative literature, religious texts (ritual manuscripts and magical spells), and historical and documentary texts recording real-life cases of the magical activities that appear in the first two types of text. Greta Van Buylaere interrogates cuneiform documents from ancient Mesopotamia—Sumer and Akkad, and later Babylonia and Assyria—from the second half of the third millennium BCE until the first century CE. Finally, Esther Eidinow analyzes a range of evidence for ritual practices, and the attitudes toward them, from ancient Greek culture in the Classical period (largely from the fifth to fourth century BCE), including magical texts, law court speeches, and medical treatises.

 

ARTICLES


Narrations of Magical Power in Ancient Egypt or: A Counter-Narrative to "Witchcraft" Concepts
Svenja Nagel

This literary piece testifies to a typical imperial-period concept of a "witch" who is practicing necromancy with "bizarre" rituals, and since her actions are deemed impious and abominable, is shortly thereafter punished by violent death. Her actions are at the same time characterized as "common practice among the women of Egypt," and thus as typical of indigenous Egyptian female practice. However, since this is a work of relatively late date from the Greco-Roman literary tradition, does it represent just an outsider view of native Egyptian practice; or does it reflect any aspect of reality in ancient Egypt, perhaps including a continuity of traditions about "witches" reaching into the Greco-Roman period? What is its relationship to comparable Egyptian narratives about practitioners of magical rituals? Are they, for instance, also characterized as impious and female?

 

The Decline of Female Professionals—and the Rise of the Witch—in the Second and Early First Millennium BCE
Greta Van Buylaere

In this article, I will examine the processes whereby women, particularly of a certain social and religious status, were marginalized and, in some cases, also demonized in second to first millennium BCE Mesopotamia. I will focus on the decline in power and legitimacy experienced by female professionals, including consecrated women such as the nadītu and qadištu, and instigated by male scholars. A certain mystery must have shrouded these women's activities in the eyes of men. Their rites and esoteric knowledge, steeped in magic, however, were not written down, leaving us with limited information about these women's expertise—limited and biased, as the male scholars were free to denigrate their female competitors, bringing them down to the level of witches. Equating these once highly respected and exclusively female professionals with witches served both to dehumanize and demonize them. They retained a degree of power and operated within a sphere of agency that could not be effectively usurped by men. It is perhaps not surprising, under these circumstances, that exorcists and qadištus did sometimes cooperate. 

 

Social Knowledge and Spiritual Insecurity: Identifying "Witchcraft" in Classical Greek Communities
Esther Eidinow

This essay begins with this Aesopic fable, because I want to argue that the gunê magos it depicts belongs to the (semantic) family of "the witch." This does not mean that I regard this term as indicating, straightforwardly, a universal category. But the conference that generated this essay was based on the assumption of the diachronic and cross-cultural conceptual power of witchcraft beliefs and practices, which encompass both local and global meanings and whose historical trajectory extends back to ancient Mediterranean cultures. The breadth of our coverage in both the conference and volume is not meant to suggest that a direct resemblance can be assumed between one set of phenomena and another across distances of time, place, and culture; nor do we intend to claim that this etic term "witch" can simply encompass or displace the emic understandings of the subjects of analysis.

 

Witchcraft and Psychosis: Perspectives from Psychopathology and Cultural Neuroscience
Quinton Deeley

In his book Witchcraft, Intimacy, and Trust, the social anthropologist Peter Geschiere—who has worked among the Maka people of southwest Cameroon since the early 1970s—relates the story of Jean Eba. Eba was a successful fonctionnaire—a civil servant and political operative—who in the late 1960s returned to his village: "Eba felt ill, his complaints were quite mysterious (general fatigue), and no doctor succeeded in curing him. So people soon started whispering about witchcraft. Apparently Eba himself shared this view, despite his Western education: after some hesitation he told me that he had begun to frequent one nganga (healer) after another. Finally a nganga from Djem country (some sixty miles away) succeeded in helping him, but insisted that he had to leave the village and return to one of the urban centers of the East."1 Local people interpreted this as an "attack from inside the house" as a result of jealousy from relatives he had not sufficiently helped, although different suspects and specific motives were identified.

 

REVIEWS

 

The Lovecraftian Poe: Essays on Influence, Reception, Interpretation and Transformation ed. by Sean Moreland (review)
Reviewed by Kyle Brett

The Salem Belle: A Tale of 1692 by Ebenezer Wheelwright (review)
Dawn Coleman

Ezili's Mirrors: Imagining Black Queer Genders by Omise'eke Natasha Tinsley (review)
De'Anna Daniels

European Magic and Witchcraft: A Reader ed. by Martha Rampton (review)
Johannes Dillinger

Insomniac Dreams: Experiments with Time by Vladimir Nabokov ed. by Gennady Barabtarlo (review)
Derek Lee

War Magic: Religion, Sorcery, and Performance ed. by Douglas S. Farrer (review)
Bradley M. Johnson

Theatre, Magic and Philosophy: William Shakespeare, John Dee and the Italian Legacy by Gabriela Dragnea Horvath (review)
Jennifer Liou

The Alchemy of Empire: Abject Materials and the Technologies of Colonialism by Rajani Sudan (review)
Laura R. Kremmel

Being Bewitched: A True Tale of Madness, Witchcraft, and Property Development Gone Wrong by Kirsten C. Uszkalo (review)
Brian P. Levack

Fairy Tale: A Very Short Introduction by Marina Warner (review)
Christina A. Jones

__________________________________

Volume 13, Number 3, Winter 2018

Articles

• • • • • • • •

 

 

 

Volume 12, Number 3, Winter 2017

• • • • • • • •

Articles

This paper surveys nineteen lead curse tablets from the sanctuary of Magna Mater and Isis in Mainz, Germany. Written in Latin, these tablets seek the divine help of Magna Mater and other deities in rectifying perceived injustices. When theorizing about cursing practices at the site, I argue that we need to look to the in situ context of the curse tablets and consider the other ritual deposits made at the sanctuary. The co-presence of votary items alongside curse tablets can aid our understanding of how the curse authors at Mainz viewed their practice, and in fact votive cult provides a compelling framework for understanding cursing at Mainz. The connection between the temple locus and cursing is illustrated by the uniformity of cursing rituals, the thematic content of the petitioners' requests, and the sites of tablet deposition. Thus, we need to reconsider the idea of cursing as a deviant religious practice and instead recognize all the ways that it fell within normative religious habits in Roman antiquity.


Cursus: An Early Thirteenth-Century Source for Nocturnal Flights and Ointments in the Work of Roland of Cremona 
pp. 314 - 330 
Ayelet Even-Ezra 

This article considers a demonological tractate authored in the 1230s by Roland of Cremona, a learned physician who became the first Dominican master of theology in Paris. The core of the article is an analysis of the interaction of the popular and the learned through his original, hitherto overlooked account of a popular practice he names cursus, a nightly orgiastic flight induced by smearing a certain ointment. Antedating by two hundred years the first known sources to mention flying ointments, and independent of earlier sources about the nightly ladies, I delineate its importance to the study of the medieval origins of the witches' sabbat.


What Père Lafitau Learned from the American Diviner 
pp. 331 - 361 
Jean-Olivier Richard 

This paper uses the writings of the Jesuit Joseph-Francois Lafitau (1681-1746) to draw attention to the role that missionary encounters played in the shaping of early Enlightenment attitudes toward magic. After spending five years among the Iroquois converts of the Sault Saint-Louis mission near Montreal, Lafitau developed important insights into the shamanic practices of the New World. Buried in his Moeurs des sauvages comparées aux moeurs des premiers temps (1724) these insights have yet to be read through the history of magic. They reveal how ceremonies witnessed in America and interpreted as curious remnants of Neoplatonic theurgy served Christian apologetics in eighteenth-century France. Lafitau's case suggests that, while the practice of magic was "waning" in some European circles, concerns about its existence and efficacy persisted both as a reality in distant lands and as an object of antiquarian inquiry



Building, Burning, and Rebuilding Bridges Anthropological and Historical Approaches to Witchcraft in Tanzania and Beyond 
pp. 362 - 401 
Eric Burton 

After a first, short-lived attempt in the 1970s, the cooperation of historical and anthropological approaches to witchcraft has recently experienced a renaissance. This article discusses both cross-fertilizations and persistent gaps in the interdisciplinary exchanges, arguing that the perception of witchcraft-related phenomena outside of Europe continues to suffer from insufficient historicization, while many historians of early modern Europe cling to a European Sonderweg which renders witchcraft in early modern as Europe unique and, ultimately, incomparable. Issues of interdisciplinary cooperation are then discussed using Tanzania as a case study.

Reviews

Witchcraft and Folk Belief in the Age of Enlightenment: Scotland, 1670–1740 by Lizanne Henderson (review) 
pp. 402 - 404 
Michelle D. Brock 

Shi'ism in South East Asia: 'Alid Piety and Sectarian Constructions ed. by Chiara Formichi and R. Michael Feener (review) 
pp. 404 - 406 
Majid Daneshgar 

Johann Reuchlin (1455–1522): A Theological Biography by Franz Posset (review) 
pp. 406 - 410 
Jason Roberts 

The Virtue of Sympathy: Magic, Philosophy, and Literature in Seventeenth-Century England by Seth Lobis (review) 
pp. 410 - 412 
Ryan J. Stark 

Cas Gan Gythraul: Demonology, Witchcraft, and Popular Magic in Eighteenth-Century Wales ed. by Lisa Tallis (review) 
pp. 412 - 414 
Richard Suggett 

Agents of Witchcraft in Early Modern Italy and Denmark by Louise Nyholm Kallestrup (review) 
pp. 414 - 416 
Gerhild Scholz Williams 

Magic in Islam by Michael Muhammad Knight (review) 
pp. 416 - 419 
Edgar Francis 

Realizing the Witch: Science, Cinema, and the Mastery of the Invisible by Richard Baxstrom and Todd Meyers (review) 
pp. 419 - 421 
Oliver Gaycken 

Witchcraft, Witch-Hunting, and Politics in Early Modern England by Peter Elmer (review) 
pp. 421 - 424 
E. J. Kent 

Beliefs and Rituals in Archaic Eastern North America: An Interpretive Guide by Cheryl Claassen (review) 
pp. 424 - 428 
Lucianne Lavin

Winter 2016 Vol. 11.2

• • • • • • • •

Articles

Witchcraft, Possession, and the Unmaking of Women and Men: A Late-Sixteenth-Century English Case Study

Erika Gasser

In pursuit of a cultural history of manhood and patriarchal power in early modern English witchcraft-possession, this article examines the case against the Samuel family in Warboys, England, from 1589 to 1593. After Robert Throckmorton’s five daughters began to act as if they were possessed, they named Alice Samuel, her husband John, and their daughter Agnes as witches. The influential published narrative of the case, entitled The Witches of Warboys (1593), reveals how patriarchal claims to legitimate authority operated through the prosecution of witches of both sexes. Compared to his wife and daughter, John Samuel was able to access power differently in the crucial settings where the drama unfolded, and he and Throckmorton found themselves locked in struggles over control of the proceedings. The Witches of Warboys case modeled a respectable family’s victory against wickedness, but at its center the implicit question of patriarchy’s vulnerability in the context of witchcraft-possession remained unresolved. This article argues that a study of early modern manhood requires mindfulness of the contingent status of men and women, and that gender played a crucial role in the attempts of suspected witches of both sexes to navigate the charges against them.

Demonic Possession in the Enlightenment: Goya’s Flying Witches 

Guy Tal

Supernatural and fantastic works hold a significant place in Francisco Goya’s oeuvre, yet their meaning is often perplexing on both iconographic and symbolic levels. Particularly enigmatic is Flying Witches (Museo del Prado), one of Goya’s six witchcraft paintings purchased in 1798 by the Duke and Duchess of Osuna. An examination of the hitherto misconstrued bodily configuration of the witches’ victim reveals the supernatural phenomenon described in the scene. Although the victim’s convulsive body invokes the pathos formula of the famous Laocoön statue group, it registers demonic possession, not generic suffering. That Goya conceived Flying Witches in its entirety as a scene of possession is supported by its similarities with two images: an illustration in Laurent Bordelon’s History of the Ridiculous Extravagancies of Monsieur Oufle and Raphael’s Transfiguration. As an expression of Enlightenment ideas, Flying Witches cues scepticism towards the supernatural and censures the Inquisition as an archaic institution.

A Halloween Bruja: On the Magical Efficacy of Stereotypical Iconic Witches

Raquel Romberg

In the early morning of Halloween in 1996, after nearly a year working intensely as an apprentice with Haydée, a bruja espiritista (Spiritist witch healer), it took me by surprise to see her wearing a golden gown and a black pointed hat as she prepared for the daily consultations at her home altar. What I saw at that time was a "real" professional Puerto Rican bruja “dressed up” as a pop-culture black-bonneted stereotypical Anglo "witch." At the center of this ethnographic essay are the exploration of the display and ritual effectiveness of the symbolic “shapeshifting” of a Puerto Rican bruja into a Halloween flying-witch, and the significance of such an iconic form of mimesis in summoning additional spiritual cosmic powers during healing and cleansing rituals. Historically, the ritual innovation of vernacular religions such as brujería illustrates the complex ways in which various seemingly unrelated and peculiar components – in this this case, colonial and postcolonial stereotypical representations of witches, home-made and mass produced ritual objects, and commodified and spiritual perceptions of the work witch healers perform – are all significantly integrated in ritual. 

Invoking Hecate at the Women’s Peace Camp: The Presence of Goddess Spirituality and Dianic Witchcraft at Greenham Common in the 1980s

Shai Feraro

This article examines the presence and importance of Goddess Spirituality and Dianic Witchcraft at the Greenham Common Women’s Peace Camp during the first decade or so of its existence. The influence of radical and cultural feminisms on the women who lived at the peace camp and assembled there for large scale anti-nuke demonstrations has been explored by many researchers in the past, but the issue of spirituality – and particularly Goddess Spirituality and feminist/Dianic Witchcraft – at the camp has yet to receive adequate scholarly attention. This article uses archival records, memoires and oral histories in order to shed some light on this under-studied phenomenon, and in addition attempts to contextualize the camp as an arena for exchanges of views and knowledge between non-feminist British Wiccans and American-influenced radical feminists and Goddess women. 

Summer 2016 Vol. 11.1

• • • • • • • •

Articles

Introduction to the Special Issue: How (and Why) Do Witches Fly?

Michael Ostling

The introduction to this special issue on witches’ imagined flight briefly traces the historiography of flight from classical antiquity into the early modern period. Witch-flight derives from a confluence of several traditions: literary depictions of metamorphosis, folkloric nightmares of child-stealing lamiae, and medieval beliefs about women who travel with Diana or similar pagan goddesses. The canon Episcopi condemned this last belief in the 10th century, but in the 15th century demonologists came to combine it with new stereotypes of a communal, diabolical witch-cult. In the early modern period, the flying witch became a “prerogative instance,” a borderline case through which to argue about the nature of reality in ways often entirely independent of the trials or confessions of accused witches.

Skepticism, Empiricism, and Proof in Gianfrancesco Pico della Mirandola’s Strix

Walter Stephens

Gianfrancesco Pico della Mirandola’s dialogue “Strix, sive de ludificatione daemonum” was published in 1523 at Bologna, to defend a witch-hunt that claimed ten victims on the author’s territory. For Gianfrancesco, the question of witches’ flight was tightly bound to the accusation that witches copulated with demons, based on Scholastic ideas of demons’ corporeality. Influenced by the value placed on witches’ “expert testimony” about human/demon interaction in Malleus maleficarum, Gianfrancesco’s dialogue dramatized the interrogation of a convicted witch by two humanists--a skeptic and a defender of witchcraft reality--under the supervision of the witch’s inquisitor. The witch herself provides crucial evidence to convince the skeptic that witches fly, copulate with demons, and commit other crimes in reality, not in dreams or hallucinations. Two decades earlier, Gianfrancesco had held the opposite conviction, stating in his “De imaginatione” that demons “ran riot” in witches’ corrupted imagination. This article traces the evolution of proofs given by the title character of Strix.

Babyfat and Belladonna: Witches’ Ointment and the Contestation of Reality

Michael Ostling

This article explores a historiographic irony: in the early modern period, those who doubted the reality of witches’ flight posited an ointment of soporific herbs (especially nightshades) to explain witches’ flight: with transvection thus explained away as the effect of phytochemicals, alleged witches must be innocent. In contrast, those who believed in the real crime of witchcraft insisted that the devil caused bodily flight, while the ointment (composed of the rendered fat of murdered babies), provided a concrete symbol of their depravity. In contemporary (20th-21st century) historiography, these positions are reversed. Most historians treat the ointment as an elite slander, while many of those who wish to assert the reality of the practice of witchcraft turn to the ointment as a scientifically explicable hallucinogenic “trip.” After demonstrating that we have no evidence that any accused witch ever used a hallucinogenic ointment, the article reflects on the continued deployment of this trope to defend reductionist models of history and of human agency.

The Flying Witch: Its Resonance in the Sixteenth-Century Netherlands

Willem de Blécourt

After the fifteenth-century Council of Basel, the distribution of witch trials across Europe did not proceed evenly as a monolithic “cumulative concept.” Rather, the different concepts such as apostasy, sabbat, and flying each spread along their own routes and showed their own dynamics. The scarcity of flying witches in the sixteenth-century Netherlands is explained by the reluctance of intellectuals to accept new witchcraft theories as expressed in the wake of the Arras trials and in the Malleus maleficarum. In the two cases wherein flying witches did occur, in the 1560s in the towns of Amsterdam and Rotterdam, the influence of visual media may be suspected.

Making Time Go Away: Magical Manipulations of Time and Space

Gerhild Scholz Williams

The process of imagining, seeing, and describing the encounter with the Other, in this case the witch, produces and transmits “facts” about magical geographies, those who inhabit them. Reading about magical propulsion in the witch’s flight transfers us into a space which, like the witches’ Sabbath, is marked by relentless motion. Like real world travel, the witches’ Sabbath presents the experience of strange and unfamiliar spaces and of the exotic, frightening, and fascinating Other. The rough and rugged landscapes of the French Labourd were believed to be so attractive to demons and witches that they decided, if not settle there, then regularly visit them. In the texts examined here, the real and imagined flight of the witch provides the reader with strange and frightening experiences as they and we contemplate the interaction of time and space and the relationships and communication between the spaces to which we accompany the witches.

The Author's Response to Last Issue's Forum on The Cooking of History

Minerva Airlines

Stephan Palmié

Reviews

Divination and Theurgy in Neoplatonism: Oracles of the Gods by Crystal Addey (review) Robert M. Berchman

The Devil: A New Biography by Philip C. Almond (review) Peter Dendle

Writing Witch-Hunt Histories: Challenging the Paradigm ed. by Marko Nenonen, Raisa Maria Toivo (review) Erika Gasser

Magical Transformations on the Early Modern English Stage ed. by Lisa Hopkins, Helen Ostovich (review) Deborah Lea

India and the Occult: The Influence of South Asian Spirituality on Modern Western Occultism by Gordan Djurdjevic (review) June McDaniel

The Empty Seashell: Witchcraft and Doubt on an Indonesian Island by Nils Bubandt (review) Jon Henrik Ziegler Remme

 

 

 

Winter 2015 Vol. 10.2

• • • • • • • •

Articles

Ciphers in Magic: Techniques of Revelation and Concealment

Benedek Láng

The rhetoric of secrecy is a recurring theme in the history of early modern science; but “secrets” and “secrecy” do not necessarily coincide. In the study of the dynamics of secrecy; the ability to withhold or share information in itself becomes a power enabling social control, regardless of the secreted content. This may be as much a matter of rhetoric as it is of a need to actually conceal information. Questions about the dynamics and rhetoric of secrecy are of special interest in the case of magic manuscripts. How much is this governed by a need to actually conceal content? This article argues that late medieval and early modern magic texts frequently included ciphers; however, they do not seem to be tools for hiding the message. Encrypting makes no content inaccessible. The function of ciphers was different: inviting engagement with the text, which can be described as a maneuver in the rhetoric of secrecy.

“An’ it Harm None, Do What Ye Will”: A Historical Analysis of the Wiccan Rede

Ethan Doyle White

In the 1950s, the English occultist Gerald Gardner (1884–1964) began propagating a magico-religious tradition now known as Gardnerian Witchcraft whose adherents today number in the hundreds of thousands. A common element of Wiccan belief is an ethical commandment known as the “Wiccan Rede,” usually articulated in the form “an' it harm none, do what ye will.” This article traces the history of the Rede, beginning with an examination of Gardner's own early ethical statements. It traces Gardner's relationship with Doreen Valiente, his collaborator who came to proclaim the Rede at a prominent Pagan gathering in October 1964, noting the influence of Crowley's law of thelema, before moving on to discuss the wider reception of the Rede within the Wiccan movement and why practitioners of many rival traditions chose to reject it.

Necromancing Theurgic Magic: A Reappraisal of the Liber iuratus Extracts and the Consecration Ritual for the Sigillum Dei in an Early Modern English Grimoire

László Sándor Chardonnens

A manuscript in the British Library, Sloane 3853, is an Early Modern magical miscellany containing substantial extracts from a work of medieval ritual magic called the Liber iuratus Honorii or Sworn Book of Honorius. Sloane 3853 has generally been neglected as a source for the Swork Book, since other British Library manuscripts have better and more complete copies. This article argues that extracts from another text known to be included in the miscellany - the Ars notoria - in fact have the Sworn book as a proximate source. Focusing on the ways the Sworn Book is adapted and used, and especially on the vernacularized instructions given for the Sigil of God, the article goes on to trace how Sloane 3853 reflects the interests of its scribe, who focused on quick and straightforward spirit conjurations, ignoring the larger ritual context of the Sworn Book, in keeping with an interest in practical necromancy.

Forum: Nail Soup, or the Power of Collaboration: Reactions to Stephan Palmie

Digesting Stephan Palmié’s Cooking of History

Michael Lambek

The “Knower” and the “Known”— Complex Articulations

Peter Geschiere

Yenye Labá, or How to Season an Afro-Caribbean Dish

Hans de Waardt

The Raw and the Overcooked: Some Comments on Stephan Palmié’s Cooking of History

Peter Pels

Turning the Pot Upside Down: What About the Cooking of Religion?

Raquel Romberg

Object Lessons: Afro-Cuban Religion at the Ethnographic Interface

Kate Ramsey

Reviews

A Coptic Handbook of Ritual Power eds. by Malcolm Choat and Iain Gardner (review)

Grant Adamson

Ritual Textuality: Pattern and Motion in Performance by Matt Tomlinson (review)

Jon Bialecki

The Celtic Evil Eye and Related Mythological Motifs in Medieval Ireland by Jacqueline Borsje (review)

Joanne Findon

Magic and Kingship in Medieval Iceland: The Construction of a Discourse of Political Resistance by Nicolas Meylan (review)

Ármann Jakobsson

Witchcraft and the Rise of the First Confucian Empire by Liang Cai (review)

Jinhua Jia

Magic in the Cloister: Pious Motives, Illicit Interests, and Occult Approaches to the Medieval Universe by Sophie Page (review)

Kathleen Kamerick

Urban Magic in Early Modern Spain: Abracadabra Omnipotens by María Tausiet (review)

George A. Klaeren

Scottish Witches and Witch-Hunters ed. by Julian Goodare (review)

P. G. Maxwell-Stuart

The Ethnopoetics of Shamanism by Marcel De Lima (review)

Silvia Tomášková

Witchcraft and a Life in the New South Africa by Isak Niehaus (review)

Nathanael M. Vlachos

Prognostic Structure and the Use of Trumps in Tibetan Pebble Divination

Alexander K. Smith
École pratique des hautes etudes

This paper discusses the structure of prognoses offered in a form of pebble divination common to the Bön religion of Tibet. In addition to fieldwork conducted at Menri Monastery, Sirmaur District, H.P., India, the discussion will be drawn primarily from an alleged witness to an eleventh century “treasure” text, as well as two divination manuals written in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries respectively. Following a brief introduction to Tibetan divination practices and to the Bön religion, the method of casting will be discussed. It will be shown that Tibetan pebble divination uses a system of ‘trumps’ that significantly complicate the distillation of prognoses. In this respect, lithomantic techniques stand apart from other Tibetan divination practices, many of which use similar numeral systems, though lack a mediating structure of ‘major’ and ‘minor’ results


The “Eye of Abraham” Charm for Thieves
Versions in Middle and Early Modern English

Stephen B. Stallcup

We are very fortunate to be able to publish an article by Stephen Stallcup, whose death in 2009 at the age of thirty-eight cut short a promising career. Stallcup was trained at Southern Methodist University and Princeton, where he received his PhD in English in 2000. He subsequently taught at the University of North Carolina at Greensboro, where he specialized in Middle English. He published on Anglo-Saxon and Early Modern topics as well, and the piece we offer here is not his only venture into magical areas. His last conference paper presented at the International Congress on Medieval Studies in May 2008, “Alma Chorus Domini: Divine Names in Religious and Magical Contexts,” was an interesting and learned exposition on the use of divine names in English liturgical and magical texts. Unfortunately he passed away before it could be published.

This article discusses and edits five versions of the “Eye of Abraham,” a charm against thieves common in Early Modern England, though in fact the procedure described in the charms is unique to neither England nor the sixteenth century. A similar charm is known to German folklorists as the Diebesauge; numerous versions are found in the folk- and magic-literature of Germany and Scandinavia, and the earliest known version occurs in an early fourth-century Greek papyrus. All the versions have in common a procedure that involves painting an eye on a wall, and striking or hitting it with a hammer or sharp object to cause the eye of the thief to water, or in the worst cases, to be put out. The five English versions edited here all show interesting differences in language and invocation.

 

Scottish Witchcraft in a Regional and Northern European Context
The Northern Highlands, 1563–1660

Thomas Brochard
University of Aberdeen

The article uses a multi-angle framework to investigate cases of witchcraft in Scotland’s northern shires between 1563 and 1660, comparing it with other mostly northern European regions. The comparatively low incidence of witchcraft accusations in these areas can be accounted for by an array of factors: a certain socio-cultural tolerance combined with the partial establishment of institutional structures and with the alternative form of judicial settlements and a greater concern for social cohesion in a society still mostly defined by kinship. The curtailment of witchcraft depended on this association of structures, actors, and on socio-economic, cultural, and religious factors acting on the localities modified by chronological and geographical variations.

 

REVIEW ESSAY

Provincializing European Witchcraft
Thoughts on Peter Geschiere’s Latest Synthesis

Michael D. Bailey
Iowa State University

This review essay offers a reaction to Peter Geschiere’s Witchcraft, Intimacy and Trust. Geschiere’s book argues hat witchcraft is essentially about the paradox that the group of people with whom we are most intimate (neighbors and kin) has, by virtue of its intimacy, tremendous power and a potentially dangerous hold over us. The remedy for this paradox is trust; when trust fails, witchcraft appears. While Geschiere’s study is primarily grounded in African witchcraft, the present essay considers the possibilities these ideas may hold for the study of witchcraft phenomena on a global scale, both historically and sociology, in other parts of the world, and especially for those who focus on Western Europe.

 

REVIEWS

Cases of Male Witchcraft in Old and New England, 1592–1692 by E.J. Kent (review)
Reviewed by Lara Apps


Aleister Crowley and the Temptation of Politics by Marco Pasi (review)
Reviewed by Gordan Djurdjevic


Spirited Things: The Work of “Possession” in Afro-Atlantic Religions ed. by Paul Christopher Johnson (review)
Reviewed by Diana Espírito Santo


The True History of Merlin the Magician by Anne Lawrence-Mathers (review)
Reviewed by Peter H. Goodrich


Magic and Masculinity: Ritual Magic and Gender in the Early Modern Era by Frances Timbers (review)
Reviewed by Ofer Hadass


Magic and Religion in Medieval England by Catherine Rider (review)
Reviewed by Katherine Hindley


Divination and Interpretation of Signs in the Ancient World ed. by Amar Annus (review)
Reviewed by Ann Jeffers


Invoking Angels: Theurgic Ideas and Practices, Thirteenth to Sixteenth Centuries ed. by Claire Fanger (review)
Reviewed by Gary K. Waite


Desperate Magic: The Moral Economy of Witchcraft in Seventeenth-Century Russia by Valerie Kivelson (review)
Reviewed by Michael Ostling 


La Corriveau: de l’histoire à la légende by Catherine Ferland, Dave Corriveau (review)
Reviewed by Stephanie Pettigrew

 

Summer 2014 Vol. 9.1

• • • • • • • •

Refined Resemblances: Three Categories of Astromagical Images in Marsilio Ficino’s De vita 3.18 and Their Indebtedness to “Abominable” BooksLauri Ockenström
University of Jyväskylä, FinlandIn the third book of his De vita libri tres, the De vita coelitus comparanda published in 1489, the Florentine philosopher Marsilio Ficino explains the pictures that the ancient “astrologers and magicians” imprinted on their talismans. He distinguishes among three pictorial conventions: visual forms, imaginable forms, and characters. The passage explaining these forms serves as a prologue to chapter 18, which gives instructions for fabricating talismans and speculates on the efficacy of magical images. This article examines Ficino’s distinctions as descending from the tradition of learned image magic, concentrating on certain iconographical and theoretical questions: What – and what kinds of – pictures did Ficino mean and on what exemplars did he base his distinction of three classes? Nightfall on Ravenna: Storms and Narrativity in the Work of Andreas AgnellusFrancesco Borri
Institut für Mittelalterforschung, ÖAWThis article examines an odd story told in Andreas Agnellus' Deeds of the Bishops of Ravenna about a certain Abbot John. The story involves a night journey to Ravenna: the vehicle is a ship drawn in the sand, and there is a rapid passage through a storm in the company of three mysterious men. Ultimately John lands not in a harbor but on the roof of his monastery. A variety of different narrative analagues are adduced to explore the origins of these disparate narrative elements and show how they were reshaped into a miraculous story by Agnellus. Shaman, Lama, Buddha: “Occult Techniques” and the Popularization of Tantric Ritual in TibetClaire Villarreal
Rice UniversityTantra is commonly referred to as “esoteric” Buddhism, yet it has become the dominant form of popular practice in Tibetan and other Himalayan cultures. In an effort to account for the popular dimension of this elite domain of practices, this article explores tantra’s transformations from a body of esoteric magico-religio-shamanic rituals in first-millennium India to a Tibetan patchwork cultural landscape in which genuinely secret practices share religious space with “open secrets” accessible to the lay public. This article has two arcs, the first examining magico-shamanic roots of tantric practices, and the second tracing the course of the new tradition’s “domestication” or “institutionalization” into more traditional Buddhism. The Tibetan embrace of tantra offers many opportunities for exploration of tensions between the popular appeal of “esoteric” traditions and the elite nature of their practice. Jewish Mysticism and Magic: An Anthropological Perspective by Maureen Bloom (review)Dustin N. Atlas
Rice University Kulturgeschichte der Mittelalterlichen Wahrsagerei by Christa Agnest Tuczay (review)Edward Bever
State University of New York College at Old Westbury Christ Transformed into a Virgin Woman. Lucia Brocadelli, Heinrich Institoris, and the Defense of Faith by Tamar Herzig (review)Fabrizio Conti
Rome Haunted Visions: Spiritualism and American Art by Charles Colbert (review)Cathy Gutierrez
Sweet Briar College Goddesses, Mages, and Wise Women: The Female Pastoral Guide in Sixteenth- and Seventeenth-Century English Drama by Sharon Rose Yang (review)Jasmine Lellock
University of Maryland, College Park Things: Religion and the Question of Materiality edited by Dick Houtman and Brigit Meyer (review)Ian Lowrie
Rice University The Witch in the Western Imagination by Lyndal Roper (review)Michael Ostling
University of Queensland Witch Beliefs and Witch Trials in the Middle Ages: Documents and Readings by P. G. Maxwell-Stuart (review)Brian A. Pavlac
King’s College, Wilkes-Barre, PA Aleister Crowley and Western Esotericism edited by Henrik Bogdan and Martin P. Starr (review)Nick Serra
Upper Iowa University The Devil Within: Possession and Exorcism in the Christian West by Brian P. Levack (review)Moshe Sluhovsky
Hebrew University of Jerusalem